The Keeper's House Isle Au Haut, Maine A lighthouse and cottage on the wild, rockbound cusp of a continent. (207) 367-2261 Website Little Palm Island Little Torch Key, Florida Caribbean fantasy island retreat. (800) 343-8567 Website Pollywogg Holler Belmont, New York An enchanted sauna cubby in a handcrafted ecolodge. (800) 291-9668 Website Randall's Ordinary North Stonington, Connecticut Fireplace-cooked meals at an ancient stagecoach-stop tavern. (860) 599-4540 Website Inn at Covered Bridge Green West Arlington, Vermont Skylit loft hideaway in Norman Rockwell's painting studio. (802) 375-9489 Website Blackthorne Inn Inverness, California Forest canopy hot tub and treehouse view atop a glass-enclosed tower. (415) 663-8621 Website Hillbrook Country House Hotel Charles Town, West Virginia Storybook estate that trickles down a Monongahela ridge. (800) 304-4223 Website The Point Upper Saranac Lake, New York A sybarite's dreamy wilderness retreat hand hewn in Adirondack bark. (800) 255-3530 Website The Barn Bed and Breakfast Dahinda, Illinois Barn-stall lodging inside a rural diorama. (309) 639-4408 Website Shack Up Inn Clarksdale, Mississippi Sharecropper's Mississippi Delta shack echoes with the blues pounded out on its upright piano. (662) 624-8329 Website